Roof Felt, Breathable Membrane or Bare Slates: What Your Underlay Means for Attic Insulation
Roof Felt, Breathable Membrane or Bare Slates: What Your Underlay Means for Attic Insulation
Every pitched roof in Dublin has something between the slates or tiles and the loft below, even if that something is nothing at all. Whether it is black bitumen felt, a lighter breathable membrane or the bare underside of the slates changes how moisture leaves the roof space once new attic insulation goes down. This post compares the three, side by side, so you know which one you have and what it asks of the job.
Why the underlay matters more after the upgrade
Before an upgrade, heat leaking through a thinly insulated ceiling keeps the roof space mild and dries it out. Lay 300 mm of insulation across the ceiling and far less of that heat reaches the loft, so the roof space becomes colder. Warm, damp air from showers, cooking and drying clothes still finds its way up through gaps around the hatch, pipes and light fittings, and when it meets a cold surface it condenses. An Irish Times property clinic on water droplets forming on roofing felt after a loft upgrade describes exactly this pattern, and points out that bituminous felt slows the air movement that would otherwise carry the moisture away.
This is all about a cold roof, where the insulation sits at ceiling level and the loft above stays unheated. If your rooms run up into the slope of the roof, our comparison of cold roof and warm roof paths for Dublin attics explains how that changes the approach.
The three underlays compared
| Bare slates, no underlay | Bitumen felt | Breathable membrane | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you see from the loft | The underside of the slates, often with daylight at the joints or old lime mortar between them | A black or dark brown sheet, often sagging between rafters and brittle near the eaves | A lighter woven or spun sheet, usually white, grey or blue |
| Where you tend to find it | Many pre-war redbrick terraces and older cottages | Most houses built or reroofed from the post-war decades until around the turn of the century | Newer homes and roofs replaced in the last twenty years or so |
| How moisture leaves the loft | Through gaps between slates and at the eaves; very draughty | Almost entirely through deliberate vents, because the felt itself is close to vapour-tight | Partly through the membrane, with eaves ventilation still expected in most existing houses |
| What new insulation must leave alone | The air path under the eaves, and any wet or rotten timber needs fixing first | Every eaves vent and soffit slot, with a clear channel between insulation and felt | The eaves air path, unless the whole roof was designed and certified as a sealed system |
| Main risk if it goes wrong | Wind-blown rain or dust settling on the insulation | Condensation dripping from the felt onto timbers and stored boxes | Lower risk, but still condensation where vents are blocked |
What the rules and certificates say
Ireland’s Technical Guidance Document F on ventilation sets the benchmark for a pitched roof over an insulated ceiling: openings at the eaves on opposite sides, adding up to at least a continuous 10 mm gap along the full length. With bitumen felt, those openings are doing nearly all the work, which is why insulation stuffed into the eaves is the fault to watch for.
Breathable membranes are often described as needing no ventilation at all. Read the small print. A typical NSAI Agrément certificate for a vapour-permeable roof underlay allows a non-ventilated cold roof only where an air and vapour control layer is installed on the warm side of the insulation. An existing Dublin ceiling with a hatch, downlights and pipe holes rarely meets that standard, so in practice the eaves stay open whatever the underlay.
Ventilation fixes compared
If an attic already shows damp, or the eaves have been blocked by an earlier job, these are the usual options, from least to most disruptive:
| Fix | What it does | Disruption | When it makes sense |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pull insulation back from the eaves | Reopens the existing air path | Low, done from inside | Always the first check |
| Eaves vent trays between rafters | Hold a clear channel between the insulation and the felt | Low, done from inside | Felt or membrane roofs getting deeper insulation |
| Extra soffit or gable vents | Add cross-flow where there is too little | Moderate, outside work | Houses with flush fascias or sparse vent slots |
| Slate or tile vents higher up | Let damp air escape near the ridge | Moderate, roofer needed | Lean-to roofs or stubborn condensation |
| Replace felt with a breathable membrane | Changes the roof build-up | High, slates or tiles lifted | Only when the roof covering is being renewed anyway |
The Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland makes the same point in its answer on water building up under the roof after extra attic insulation: check the eaves and vent spacing first, because replacing the felt means removing and reinstating tiles and battens. Cutting the moisture at source helps too. Seal the hatch, close gaps around pipes and cables, and make sure bathroom extractor fans are ducted outside rather than into the loft.
Older slate roofs with no underlay
Roofs without any underlay are naturally well ventilated, which is good news for condensation. The care point is different. The national Advice Series booklet on energy efficiency in traditional buildings says that where no formal vents exist, enough air usually comes in through gaps at the eaves, so the insulation must be laid to keep that flow going. It also notes that new roof vents on a protected structure or in an architectural conservation area may need permission.
The more detailed 2023 guidance for specifiers and installers working on traditional buildings adds that roof insulation should be achieved without damaging the slating, whether during the works or later through condensation. On these roofs, a survey looks at slate condition, any old lime mortar on the underside of the slates and the state of the timbers before anything is laid.
Where the grant fits
The SEAI attic insulation grant is a fixed €1,100 to €2,000 depending on house type, or up to €2,500 for eligible first-time buyers, welfare recipients and HAP or RAS landlords, and it is approved before any work begins. Keeping the eaves clear is part of a properly installed job, whichever underlay you have. If SEAI does not approve your application, no work starts and you pay nothing, and our installs carry a 15-year guarantee.
Knowing your underlay is one of the first questions on a survey for home energy upgrades anywhere in Dublin, and it takes a couple of minutes to answer. To book yours, Claim Your Grants for attic insulation in Dublin or call us on 01-233-7477.
Claim Your Grants
See your grant figure