Mineral Wool, Sheep’s Wool, Blown Fibre or PIR Boards: Attic Insulation Materials Compared

Oval-head stick figure in beige bucket hat and orange-and-blue striped scarf stands in an attic between a quilt roll, a pile of sheep’s wool, a heap of loose-fill and a stack of rigid boards, cream paper explainer comic.

Ask three contractors to price the same Dublin attic and you can get three different materials on the quotes. One says rolls of mineral wool, one says blown fibre, one mentions rigid boards. None of them is automatically wrong. They suit different roofs, different access and different plans for the space. This post puts the common options side by side in one table, then explains where each one earns its place.

Oval-head stick figure in beige bucket hat and orange-and-blue striped scarf stands in an attic between a quilt roll, a pile of sheep’s wool, a heap of loose-fill and a stack of rigid boards, cream paper explainer comic.
Oval-head stick figure in beige bucket hat and orange-and-blue striped scarf stands in an attic between a quilt roll, a pile of sheep’s wool, a heap of loose-fill and a stack of rigid boards, cream paper explainer comic.

The short answer

For a cold roof that is only used for storage, a deep layer of quilt laid across the ceiling joists is still the standard choice, and it is what most attic insulation in Dublin semis and terraces looks like after a grant job. Blown fibre is the better tool when the attic is awkward to crawl through or full of low corners. Rigid boards belong mostly at rafter level, which is a different job with different rules. Sheep’s wool and hemp are real options that meet the same performance bar, at a higher price.

SEAI’s own homeowner’s guide to attic and rafter insulation names mineral fibre, glass fibre, hemp and sheep’s wool quilts as all capable of meeting the scheme’s requirements, and asks for the quilt to go down in two layers laid in two directions.

The comparison table

Lambda is the thermal conductivity of the material. Lower means less heat gets through each millimetre. The figures below are typical declared ranges; the real number is printed on the product label or its data sheet, so check that rather than trusting a table.

Material Typical lambda (W/mK) Best fit Watch out for
Glass mineral wool quilt (rolls) 0.040 to 0.044 Open cold-roof attics at ceiling level, laid between and then across the joists Itchy to handle; it only works at full loft depth, so it must not be squashed under boards
Rock mineral wool quilt or slab 0.035 to 0.044 Ceiling level where a denser, slightly better-performing quilt is wanted Heavier rolls; same rule about crushing and eaves airflow
Sheep’s wool or hemp quilt About 0.038 to 0.040 Ceiling level for owners who want a natural fibre that is pleasant to handle Usually costs more per square metre; thickness for the same result is similar to mineral wool
Blown mineral fibre or cellulose (loose-fill) About 0.038 to 0.045 Shallow, cluttered or hard-to-reach attics, low eaves, topping up between existing joists Needs an even depth and depth markers; can drift if eaves vents are not baffled
Rigid PIR boards 0.022 to 0.026 Rafter level for a room-in-roof, or where depth is tight Needs careful cutting and a ventilated gap; not the usual choice for an open storage attic floor

Where each one earns its place

Quilt across the joists

If you only use the attic for storage, SEAI’s guide to insulation upgrades recommends insulating at ceiling level, keeping the heat in the rooms below and leaving the attic cold, with 300mm as the ideal depth. Rolls are quick to lay in an open loft, the first layer fills the space between the joists, and the second runs across them so the timber is not left as a cold line.

Stick figure in bucket hat and striped scarf kneels on a board and blows loose-fill insulation towards low eaves while quilt fills the joist bays, cream paper explainer comic, no text.
Stick figure in bucket hat and striped scarf kneels on a board and blows loose-fill insulation towards low eaves while quilt fills the joist bays, cream paper explainer comic, no text.

Blown fibre for awkward attics

Some attics are a crawl: low pitch, trussed rafters close together, water tanks and pipework in the way. Getting rolls tight into every corner there is slow and gaps creep in. Blown fibre goes in through a hose and settles into the corners. Ask what product is being used and whether it carries third-party certification such as an NSAI Agrément certificate, and ask how the installer will keep the eaves clear.

Rigid boards at the rafters

Boards make sense where the insulation has to follow the slope of the roof, which usually means an existing room in the roof. SEAI’s technical bulletin on roof insulation and ventilation asks for at least a 25mm gap at the eaves for ceiling-level jobs and a continuous vented space of at least 50mm between the top of rafter insulation and the roof covering. If you are weighing ceiling level against rafter level, our post on cold roof vs warm roof attic insulation walks through that choice.

Stick figure in bucket hat and striped scarf holds up a blank ruler beside deep quilt on the attic floor and rigid boards fitted at the sloping rafters, cream paper explainer comic, no text.
Stick figure in bucket hat and striped scarf holds up a blank ruler beside deep quilt on the attic floor and rigid boards fitted at the sloping rafters, cream paper explainer comic, no text.

Why thickness alone does not settle it

The resistance of a layer is its thickness divided by its lambda. A 300mm quilt at 0.044 gives about 6.8 m²K/W. To match that with PIR at 0.022 you would need roughly 150mm, half the depth. That is why boards are useful where space is tight, and why they are rarely worth the extra cost on an open attic floor where there is room for a deep quilt.

The grant scheme sets the bar by result, not by brand. The same SEAI guide asks for a U-value of 0.16 W/m²K at ceiling level and 0.20 W/m²K at rafter level. Those targets sit alongside the national standard in Technical Guidance Document L for dwellings, which covers existing homes as well as new builds.

Questions to put to whoever quotes

  • Which material, which product, and what is its declared lambda?
  • What finished depth will the attic have, and how will it be marked?
  • How will the eaves stay open for airflow?
  • Will the water tank, pipework and hatch be insulated too?
  • If I store things up there, where will the walkway go, and will anything be laid on top of the quilt?
  • How will the crew handle mineral wool safely? The Health and Safety Authority’s information sheet on machine-made mineral fibres sets out the gloves, goggles and P2 masks a careful crew should use.

Grant, sign-off and next step

Whichever material suits your roof, SEAI pays a fixed attic insulation grant of €1,100 to €2,500 depending on the home type and who is applying, as long as the grant is approved before work starts and a registered contractor does the job.

Attic work is often the first of several home energy upgrades for a Dublin house, and the right material depends on what we find when we look in. To Claim Your Grants, call 01-233-7477 or book a survey for attic insulation in Dublin.

Claim Your Grants

See your grant figure

Claim Your Grants